What’s Wrong With Me?

“To be frank with you, I’m ridiculously surprised that your response rate has been so low. Your cute, your profile is good…,” was the first few lines of Laurie’s response concerning my lack of success with OkCupid. Even with the increased message count, I wasn’t receiving many responses. I feel I’ve become the ultimate dating enigma.
I like OkCupid, but maybe the population on the website isn’t geared for me. Laurie suggested that I switch over to Plenty of Fish, or as I like to call it Plenty of Fail! I’m not a fan of their dating website, it’s horribly put together, ugly, and not ad deep as OkCupid. However my lack of major success on the website leaves me little alternatives.
As I try to rationalize moving from one website to another, I do my best to stall by going out, trying some of the tips Thomas shows me. Nothing is really working, it’s clear I need more help. Every so often there’s a glimmer of hope, maybe a girl who would open up to me, give me her number after a late night discussion at a bar. Maybe the girl who was biting my neck while my hand grabbed her butt underneath her pants would want spend the rest of the evening with me. She doesn’t. These glimmer of hopes aren’t glimmers, they’re me spiraling out of control in frustration while consuming way too much alcohol. I’m trying to make up with failures with additional failure.
I sit back and examine Laurie’s comment. It only leads to more questions, why haven’t I been getting the type of response from women if I’m cute, have a good profile, and using the same techniques that work for everyone else? What’s wrong with me?
Outside of my mistakes, it’s these questions I feel are turning me into a dating enigma.
Image Source: Gabriela Camerotti on Flickr



Comments (12)
Trackbacks
If you go into PoF with the mindset that it’s the move of a desperate man… that means you see yourself as desperate. And frustrated. How you see yourself is how others see you, whether you verbalize it or not. Which is why you’re getting a poor response.
Please stop seeing yourself through your eyes, and start seeing yourself through mine.
I felt really unpopular on the last dating website I was on, even though a few men contacted me to say that mine was the best profile they’d read.
Maybe we are too good?! That’s what I like to pretend anyway!!!
I would love to think that’s the case, that I’m too good, but I know better to delude myself. It’s good to think that way when I need an ego boost however!
You know how you seem to find what you’re looking for when you’re not looking for it? Maybe this is one of those things….
just a thought :)
Ugh, I feel your pain. I did not have any luck at all on PoF (I actually had to create my profile three times because I would sign up, log off and try to log on again and my profile had been deleted) I actually just tried OkCupid a few weeks ago and did not have any luck on there either. Strangely enough, I got a few responses from people outside of the US.
I guess I must be a dating enigma as well, I think my profile pics are good, I took a great deal of time to actually write the profile and still nothing. I’m starting to take it personally….
I read on OkCupid’s blog about the study they did of 7,000 of their users. They looked at the success rate of each member’s picture and determined…
1. guys should look away from the camera and not smile (we like to think you’re mysterious i guess)
2. If you are under 20, you should pose without a shirt. After 20, forget it.
Maybe you can try this out and see what happens…
I saw that post and going to write something on it shortly. The picture isn’t everything here, I’m getting a lot of looks just no responses to the messages I’m sending out, so there HAS to be something more! Not taking my shirt off. That’s pretty much horrible advice period, I believe.
P.S. Plenty of Fish is kinda sucky. Lots of sketchy dates from that one for me.
Maybe you are just trying to hard? My advice, go out and have fun if you meet a girl great, if not then at least you had a good time. Just be yourself.
I would agree with this at times. Working on not trying to think too much.
I think it is feast or famine on these sites. I’ll get a lot of email on OkCupid then nothing for awhile then a bunch of mail again. Same with POF. I think people online are sometimes unrealistic and will not reply to an email just b/c of some random thing in a profile. With that in mind, I say just message anyone remotely interesting and the one that you think will be so-so will turn out to be great. That has been my experience. Love your blog!
Wait a minute, wait a minute, wait a minute. I recommended you branch OUT to PoF not switch! Broadening your horizons is never a bad thing, m’dear.